A basket of red snapper
WASHINGTON — Internal memos show top Trump administration officials knew extending the recreational fishing season in the Gulf of Mexico from three to 42 days this summer would lead to significant overfishing
But they did it anyway.
In memos released in response to a lawsuit, Commerce Department officials defended the move by saying that keeping the three-day season would be “devastating” to the recreational marine industry and the communities whose economies are tied to it.
And extending the time would also help solve a long-running dispute with states who have much longer seasons and want to wrest control of red snapper management from federal managers, they argued.
“It would result in overfishing of the stock by six million pounds (40%), which will draw criticism from environmental groups and commercial fishermen,” Earl Comstock, director of Policy and Strategic Planning for Commerce, conceded in a June 1 memo to his boss, Secretary Wilbur Ross. “However NMFS (National Marine Fisheries Service) agrees that this stock could handle this level on a temporary basis.”
And, Comstock noted in the memo, there was little opponents could do about it because the law governing federal fisheries — the Magnuson Stevens Act — prevents a judge from issuing a temporary restraining order “so your action would remain in effect for at least 45 days before a court could act.”
Ross, whose department oversee federal fisheries, announced the extension two weeks later.
More: Under Trump, recreational anglers feel tide turning in their favor on red snapper
Related: Red snapper fishing change raises concern
Comstock’s memo, as well as one on June 7 he wrote to Ross laying out the rationale for an extension, were filed by the government in response to a lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court in Washington, D.C., against the Commerce secretary by Ocean Conservancy and the Environmental Defense Fund. A judge could rule by the end of the year.
The environmental groups say the memos prove Commerce officials intentionally violated the Magnuson Steven Act, the law governing federal fish policy, by extending the season in the federal waters off five states — Alabama, Florida, Louisiana, Mississippi and Texas — when they knew it would lead to overfishing.
Specifically, they point to a provision in the law known as National Standard 1 which states that “conservation and management measures shall prevent overfishing while achieving, on a continuing basis, the optimum yield from each fishery for the United States fishing industry.”
“We now have alarming proof that the Department of Commerce knew their decision was illegal, would result in overfishing, and would hurt fishermen by causing significant reductions in fishing next year,” said Meredith Moore, director of the Fish Conservation Program at the Ocean Conservancy. “We need solutions that keep our oceans healthy for the long-term, not short-term work-arounds that bypass the law and benefit some at the cost of others.”
A spokesman from the Commerce Department declined comment citing the pending lawsuit.
The wrangling over who gets to fish for red snapper and for how long has become one of the nation’s most contentious fights regarding animal management.
Over the past several years, red snapper has pitted federal managers against state regulators, commercial fishing interests against recreational anglers, and sportsmen against environmentalists — all arguing over how much red snapper can be pulled out of the water while still helping the stock rebound to full health.
The decision to extend the season marked another defeat for environmentalists who have watched President Trump pull out of the Paris accord to limit greenhouse gas emissions, propose deep cuts to the Environmental Protection Agency, and move to open more off-shore waters to oil and gas drilling.
Commercial fishing interests and charter boat captains didn’t like the extension either, fearing it could add to overfishing and eat into their quotas.
But recreational anglers view the extended federal season as simply restoring balance following years of what they saw as overly restrictive catch limits imposed by the Obama administration given the abundance of red snapper they have been seeing in the water.
At the time of the announcement, Mike Leonard, conservation director for the American Sportfishing Association called the announcement “a welcome relief for the thousands of tackle shops, marinas, equipment manufacturers and other businesses who have suffered from decreasing public access to Gulf red snapper in recent years.”
States which control the immediate waters off their shorelines, agree with the industry that federal managers have undercounted the red snapper stock in the Gulf.
US Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross.
In his memos to Ross, Comstock noted Gulf states would be making a key concession because they would agree to align their much longer seasons with the federal one. Alabama, Florida, Louisiana and Mississippi are expected to give up their fall seasons, leaving Texas as the only state allowing recreational fishing through the end of the year.
The memos reveal the political considerations behind Ross’ decision.
In late May, about a dozen Gulf Coast lawmakers led by Louisiana Republican Steve Scalise approached Comstock to pitch a longer season after Commerce had announced a three-day season in federal waters that was the shortest on record. All five states have pushed Congress for legislation that would hand over management of the federal red snapper fishery to them.
Comstock spoke with fishery managers from the states who said they would consider shortening their summer seasons if the federal season was extended. Two extensions were discussed: one for 27 days and one for 39. Both would allow recreational anglers to fish on weekends through Labor Day.
State waters extend out nine miles from shore in Florida and Texas and three miles in Alabama, Louisiana and Mississippi, although it's been extended to nine miles temporarily for all three.
The options would result in the overall catch limit to be exceeded between 30% and 50% and slow down the rebuilding of red snapper in the Gulf, but NMFS "assessed the impact of such an overage and it does not threaten the health of the stock," Comstock wrote in the June 7 memo.
In asking Ross for his approval to continue negotiations, Comstock noted in the June 7 memo that commercial fishermen and charter boat captains are likely to oppose the move for fear that the overfishing being allowed would eat into their quotas for next year.
But he urged Ross to move forward with an extension.
"Approving either option would reset the debate, demonstrate (Commerce) can work with states, address a serious economic harm to business, reduce a major source of constituent frustration and benefit the fishery long term by aligning the state and federal seasons," he wrote.
David Krebs, a commercial fisherman from Destin, Fl., disagrees, saying the decision threatens the livelihood of both the stock and the other stakeholders who depend on red snapper for their livelihood.
"You're going against what the science says is the allowable catch and you will do harm to the resource long-term," he said. "It's just common sense."
The Trump presidency: A new era in Washington
Trump arrives at Andrews Air Force Base after naming John Kelly as his new chief of staff on July 28, 2017.
Trump, accompanied by Vice President Pence and Health and Human Services Secretary Tom Price, speaks about health care on July 24, 2017, in the Blue Room of the White House.
Trump, flanked by Sens. Dean Heller, R-Nev., and Tim Scott, R-S.C., speaks at a luncheon with GOP senators on July 19, 2017, in the State Dinning Room of the White House.
Trump holds a proclamation for Made in America Day and Made In America Week that he signed during a product showcase in the East Room of the White House on July 17, 2017.
French President Emmanuel Macron and Trump speak as they leave Les Invalides in Paris on July 13, 2017.
Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin hold a meeting on the sidelines of the G20 Summit in Hamburg, Germany, on July 7, 2017.
Trump walks with South Korean President Moon Jae-in to make statements in the Rose Garden on June 30, 2017.
President Trump and Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi embrace while delivering joint statements in the Rose Garden of the White House on June 26, 2017.
The Trumps watch as Panamanian President Juan Carlos Varela and his wife, Lorena Castillo, depart the White House on June 19, 2017.
Trump speaks in the Diplomatic Room of the White House on June 14, 2017, to talk about the shooting in Alexandria, Va., where House Majority Whip Steve Scalise and others were shot during a congressional baseball practice.
Trump smiles as he walks with his daughter Ivanka across the South Lawn of the White House on June 13, 2017, before boarding Marine One helicopter for the trip to nearby Andrews Air Force Base.
Trump waves to the crowd after delivering a speech on June 7, 2017, in Cincinnati.
Trump announces his decision for the United States to pull out of the Paris climate agreement in the Rose Garden at the White House on June 1, 2017.
Trump joins G7 leaders for a photo at the Ancient Greek Theater of Taormina on May 26, 2017, in Taormina, Italy.
Pope Francis greets Trump at the Vatican on May 24, 2017.
The president and first lady step off Air Force One upon arrival at Rome's Fiumicino Airport on May 23, 2017.
Trump touches the Western Wall in Jerusalem's Old City on May 22, 2017.
Trump speaks during the Arabic Islamic American Summit at the King Abdulaziz Conference Center in Riyadh on May 21, 2017.
Trump meets with Henry Kissinger in the Oval Office on May 10, 2017.
President Trump, Speaker Paul Ryan and other congressional Republicans celebrate in the Rose Garden of the White House following the House vote to repeal Obamacare on May 4, 2017.
Trump pauses as he speaks at the Pennsylvania Farm Show Complex and Expo Center in Harrisburg, Pa., on April, 29, 2017.
President Trump speaks during the National Rifle Association-ILA Leadership Forum on April 28, 2017, in Atlanta.
Secretary of the Interior Ryan Zinke listens while Trump speaks before signing an executive order to review the Antiquities Act at the Department of the Interior on April 26, 2017.
Trump prepares to award a Purple Heart to U.S. Army Sgt. 1st Class Alvaro Barrientos, with first lady Melania Trump, right, and Tammy Barrientos, second from right, at Walter Reed National Military Medical Center on April 22, 2017, in Bethesda, Md.
Trump waves as he and Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin walk from the White House to the U.S. Treasury Department on April 21, 2017.
New England Patriots head coach Bill Belichick, President Trump, Patriots owner Robert Kraft and Patriots President Jonathan Kraft stand with Patriots players as Trump holds a team helmet at a ceremony honoring the Patriots as Super Bowl champions on the South Lawn at the White House on April 19, 2017.
Trump joins attendees at the Easter Egg Roll to write notes to servicemembers on the South Lawn of the White House on April 17, 2017.
Trump speaks in the Rose Garden of the White House on April 10, 2017, at the swearing-in ceremony for Supreme Court Justice Neil Gorsuch.
Trump pumps his fist as he and Chinese President Xi Jinping walk together at the Mar-a-Lago estate in West Palm Beach, Fla., on April 7, 2017.
President Trump walks to the podium to speak about the missile strike on Syria on April 6, 2017, at Mar-a-Lago in Palm Beach, Fla.
President Trump and Jordan's King Abdullah II hold a news conference in the Rose Garden at the White House on April 5, 2017.
President Trump, flanked by Health and Human Services Secretary Tom Price and Vice President Pence, speaks about the health care overhaul bill on March 24, 2017, in the Oval Office.
Trump gets in the driver's seat of an 18-wheeler while meeting with truck drivers and trucking CEOs on the South Portico prior to their meeting to discuss health care at the White House on March 23, 2017.
President Trump speaks during a meeting with Congressional Black Caucus members in the Cabinet Room at the White House on March 22, 2017.
Trump holds a NASA flight jacket presented to him by NASA Astronaut Office Chief Chris Cassidy after signing the NASA Transition Authorization Act of 2017 in the Oval Office on March 21, 2017.
Trump and Health and Human Services Secretary Tom Price arrive on Capitol Hill on March 21, 2017, to meet with GOP lawmakers on the Republican health care overhaul.
Trump and German Chancellor Angela Merkel walk down the Cross Hall to enter the East Room for a joint press conference at the White House on March 17, 2017.
Trump talks with House Speaker Paul Ryan on Capitol Hill on March 16, 2017, during a "Friends of Ireland" luncheon.
Trump speaks to auto workers at the American Center for Mobility on March 15, 2017, in Ypsilanti, Mich.
Trump holds up a note and drawing depicting him that was created by the child of Greg Knox of Ohio during a meeting on health care in the Roosevelt Room on March 13, 2017.
Trump gestures as he surprises visitors during the official reopening of public tours at the White House on March 7, 2017.
Trump walks with grandchildren Arabella Kushner and Joseph Kushner, holding a model of Marine One, across the South Lawn of the White House on March 3, 2017, before boarding Marine One helicopter for the short flight to nearby Andrews Air Force Base.
Trump tours the Combat Direction Center on the pre-commissioned USS Gerald R. Ford aircraft carrier in Newport News, Va., on March 2, 2017.
President Trump speaks before a joint session of Congress on Feb. 28, 2017.
Trump holds up an executive order to bolster historically black colleges and universities after signing it in the Oval Office on Feb. 28, 2017.
Trump reaches out to shake hands with Army Lt. Gen. H.R. McMaster at his Mar-a-Lago estate in Palm Beach, Fla., on Feb. 20, 2017, where Trump announced that McMaster will be the new national security adviser.
The Trumps attend a campaign-style rally on Feb. 18, 2017, in Melbourne, Fla.
President Trump walks with his grandchildren Arabella Kushner and Joseph Kushner to Marine One on the South Lawn of the White House on Feb. 17, 2017.
Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu shake hands during a joint news conference in the East Room of the White House on Feb. 15, 2017.
Trump and Education Secretary Betsy DeVos attend a meeting with parents and teachers on Feb. 14, 2017, in the Roosevelt Room of the White House.
Trump looks on as Steven Mnuchin is sworn in as Treasury secretary on Feb. 13, 2017.
Trump meets with Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau in the Oval Office on Feb. 13, 2017.
Trump and Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe listen to the translator after they both made statements about North Korea at Mar-a-Lago on Feb. 11, 2017.
President Trump speaks to Democratic and Republican senators about Supreme Court nominee Neil Gorsuch in the Roosevelt Room on Feb. 9, 2017.
Intel CEO Brian Krzanich speaks during a meeting with Trump on Feb. 8, 2017, where Intel announced an investment of $7 billion to build a factory in Chandler, Ariz., to create advanced semi-conductor chips.
Trump holds up a gift given to him by county sheriffs following a meeting as they pose for photos in the Oval Office on Feb. 7, 2017.
President Trump has lunch with troops during a visit to the U.S. Central Command at MacDill Air Force Base on Feb. 6, 2017, in Tampa, Fla.
The Trumps watch the Super Bowl at a party at Trump International Golf Club in West Palm Beach, Fla., on Feb. 5, 2017.
The Trumps arrive for the 60th Annual Red Cross Gala at his Mar-a-Lago estate in Palm Beach, Fla., on on Feb. 4, 2017.
White House Chief of Staff Reince Priebus and Vice President Pence look on as Trump speaks briefly to reporters after greeting Harley Davidson executives on the South Lawn of the White House on Feb. 2, 2017.
Trump shakes hands with Neil Gorsuch, his Supreme Court nominee, in the East Room of the White House on Jan. 31, 2017.
President Trump speaks on the phone with German Chancellor Angela Merkel in the Oval Office on Jan. 28, 2017.
Trump shakes hands with Defense Secretary James Mattis during an event at the Pentagon on Jan. 27, 2017. Vice President Pence is at right.
Trump greets British Prime Minister Theresa May as she arrives at the White House on Jan. 27, 2017.
Senate Majority Whip John Cornyn and Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell watch as President Trump arrives to speak to House and Senate GOP lawmakers at the annual policy retreat in Philadelphia on Jan. 26, 2017.
Trump boards Air Force One at Andrews Air Force Base in Maryland on Jan. 26, 2017, as he departed to attend a Republican congressional retreat in Philadelphia.
Trump, accompanied by Vice President Mike Pence, gives a thumbs-up on Jan. 25, 2017, at the White House.
Trump reads from one of the executive orders he signed during a visit to the Department of Homeland Security with Vice President Mike Pence, Homeland Security Secretary John Kelly and other officials in Washington on Jan. 25, 2017.
Trump displays one of five executive actions he signed in the Oval Office on Jan. 24, 2017.
Trump speaks during a reception for House and Senate leaders in the the State Dining Room of the White House on Jan. 23, 2017.
Trump signs executive actions in the Oval Office on Jan. 23, 2017.
Trump meets with business leaders on Jan. 23, 2017, in the Roosevelt Room.
President Trump holds a letter left for him by former president Barack Obama as Vice President Pence looks on before the swearing-in of the White House senior staff on Jan. 22, 2017.
Trump speaks at the CIA headquarters in Langley, Va., on Jan. 21, 2017.
The Trumps and Pences attend the Freedom Ball on Jan. 20, 2017.
Trump is joined by the congressional leadership and his family as he formally signs his cabinet nominations into law in the Presidents Room of the Senate on Jan. 20, 2017.
Trump and Obama arrive for Trump's inauguration luncheon at the Capitol.
The Trumps and Obamas stand on the steps of the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 20, 2017.
Trump delivers his inaugural address on Jan. 20, 2017, on the west front of the U.S. Capitol
Copyright 2017 USATODAY.com