Reaction continues to Cleveland Indians beat writer Paul Hoynes' polarizing piece

CLEVELAND - and Plain Dealer beat writer Paul Hoynes has covered the Cleveland Indians for decades.

But on Saturday, Hoynes penned a piece that's created more controversy than the Progressive Field press box has seen in those decades.

Saturday was the day Indians' pitcher Carlos Carrasco saw his season end with one pitch as Detroit second baseman Ian Kinsler shot a line drive off Carrasco's right wrist. Carrasco left the game immediately and by the end of the game (a 10-inning walk-off Indians win), the team announced Carrasco had suffered a pinky fracture that would end his season.

So despite Jose Ramirez's heroics and the bullpen's stellar performance for a victory over the main division rival, the gloomy news that the Indians must head into the postseason without their No. 2 and 3 starters (Danny Salazar remains out with a forearm strain) was a prevalent storyline.

As a result, Hoynes wrote a piece that left some confused and many furious.

The headline?: "Sept. 17: The day Cleveland Indians' postseason dreams ended before they began"

The lead?: "The Indians won a ballgame Saturday afternoon, but their postseason dreams ended." Hoynes followed that up with a second graf stating, "Write it down. On Sept. 17, the Indians were eliminated from serious postseason advancement before they even got there."

Indians fans had plenty to say:

But Indians players themselves also had strong responses to the article. Even the Indians' team Twitter account reacted:

Bauer's tweets came as a result of Hoynes taking Sunday off, a scheduled off day and the day following publication of his controversial article. He also remained offline until Sunday evening until he tweeted:

But the backlash has been so heavy, Hoynes is scheduled to discuss his article in a Facebook Live video Tuesday at 6 p.m. on's Facebook page. Chris Quinn, vice president of content to, also addressed the article in a piece published Tuesday morning, defending Hoynes' article.

Tuesday night's game against the Kansas City Royals marks Hoynes' first game since his piece was published. On Tuesday morning, he wrote a new piece, explaining why he wrote the original.

How do you think the players will react? Do you think Hoynes had a right to say the Indians' season is over? Head over to WKYC's Facebook page to comment with your opinion.


To find out more about Facebook commenting please read the
Conversation Guidelines and FAQs

Leave a Comment