Breaking News
More () »

How safe is that ice cream?

Undercover tests provide a scoop

CLEVELAND — Outside of the calories, there aren’t many downsides to ice cream.

But while it remains an American pleasure, it’s one food that can turn our stomachs inside out under some conditions.

It’s particularly true with soft-serve ice cream dispensed at ice cream shops and restaurants around the country.

The culprit is coliform, a bacteria that grows largely due to a lack of hygiene. It’s the reason why it’s important that the machine that dispenses soft-serve ice cream be cleaned regularly. And why it’s important that the hands of workers be washed.

Coliform can cause a variety of ailments, such as nausea, diarrhea and vomiting.

"If there is an issue with coliform, it usually indicates that someone isn't washing their hands well, maybe someone is ill working in a facility or someone didn't clean and sanitize the equipment properly," said Lavone Lee of the Cuyahoga County Health Department.

Click here to find health department reports on all food businesses. 

While the health department does not routinely test specifically for coliform, they do inspect food service businesses for signs of potential bacteria growth. That includes cleanliness.

Channel 3 News decided to do its own undercover testing. Producers visited 12 random ice cream stores across the Cleveland area, purchasing ice cream cones. A portion of the cone was placed in a sterile bottle, marked with only a number.

The samples were then kept inside an ice cooler before they were taken to a private lab in Twinsburg. The samples were then tested for coliform.

None of the 12 showed significant amounts of coliform that would cause anyone to feel ill.

Darlene Lupica, who owns Classic Ice Cream on Denison Avenue on Cleveland’s west side, was unaware that her store was one of the tested businesses. Afterward, she said the results did not surprise her.

She said their soft-serve machine is cleaned regularly to avoid any contamination.

“Cleanliness is everything,” she said. “I wouldn’t be where I am today if it wasn’t clean.”

The other stores checked include:

  • The Apple Cart, East 43 Street and Superior Ave.
  • McDonald's on West 117th Street near Detroit Ave.
  • Dairy Queen, West 105th and Linnet Ave.
  • Lumpy's on Pearl Road.
  • East Coast Custard on Pearl Road.
  • Zero Zest on State Road.
  • Dairy King on Brecksville Road.
  • Mr. T's on Broadway Road.
  • Rally's on Mayfield Road.
  • Dairy King on Mayfield Road
  • Wendy's on West 30th and Lorain Ave.

Before You Leave, Check This Out