BAY VILLAGE, Ohio — Thirty years ago, Bay Village Police Chief Mark Spaetzel spoke to an elementary school about the dangers of strangers.

Little did he know that a 10-year-old girl in his audience would become the victim of one that very afternoon.

Amy Mihaljevic would meet a man after school who had asked her to go shopping to help pick out a present for her mom—and Amy would never come home.

To this day her bike remains in the department’s evidence room, tires deflated.

In episode 2 of Amy Should Be Forty, you will learn about the suspects in her murder. Did she know her killer?

Amy Should Be Forty is available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Podbean, Stitcher and Google Play. 3News will spotlight an episode every Wednesday through Dec. 11, which would have been Amy Mihaljevic’s birthday.

EXTENDED COVERAGE: Amy Should Be Forty: A look back on the murder case of Bay Village's Amy Mihaljevic

RELATED: 'Amy Should Be Forty' podcast hosts answer listener questions on the Amy Mihaljevic murder case

RELATED: 3News' 'Amy Should Be Forty' featured in Vulture's True-Crime Podcasts