Breaking News
More () »

Cleveland attorney says Myles Garrett’s actions crossed the line, but would be difficult to prosecute

John J. Spellacy says all circumstances around fight would have to be considered.

CLEVELAND — In the ring, on the ice, on the court, and on the field: Violence is part of sports.

But when do hard hits or a momentary loss of control become assault?

Browns defensive end Myles Garrett’s Thursday-night attack on Steelers quarterback Mason Rudolph is testing that question, again.

RELATED: Browns' Myles Garrett suspended for at least remainder of 2019 season

Sports are littered with far more violent acts that have provoked mixed legal reactions.

Mike Tyson bit off Evander Hollyfield’s ear in the ring and never faced charges. Hockey player Marty McSorely was found guilty of assault with a weapon after he struck a player in the head in the waning seconds of a game.

Garrett hit Rudolph’s bare head with a helmet.

John J. Spellacy, a Cleveland attorney a former college linebacker, said Garrett’s actions were clearly out of bounds. But he said it will be tough to prosecute him for assault, especially felonious assault.

“I don’t see this as a prosecutable case for assault,” he said. “You have to look at all the facts and circumstances surrounding the case.”

He said those include the events leading up to Garrett swinging his helmet.

“You have to look at the initial aggressor,” he said. “You see Mason Rudolph starts it. And then [Garrett and Rudolph] are separated and then Rudolph goes after Myles Garrett.”

He said Rudolph’s injuries also would have to be weighed.

“So clearly here you don’t have serious physical harm and you don’t have a deadly weapon despite someone may claim you do, but I don’t think a football helmet is a deadly weapon,” he said. 

Cleveland police said Rudolph did not file a report before leaving town, so Garrett is not facing criminal charges. The county prosecutor is not involved in the case but could review the incident for felony charges if Rudolph comes forward.  

RELATED: Cleveland police say no report, charges filed against Browns DE Myles Garrett; Mason Rudolph's agent reviewing incident

'BUSH LEAGUE': Pittsburgh Steelers QB Mason Rudolph responds to Myles Garrett’s on-field assault

Rudolph's agent Tim Younger, an attorney, posted a statement on Twitter complaining about Garrett.

“There are many risks an NFL QB assumes with every snap taken on the field. Being hit on your uncovered head by a helmet being swung by a 275 lb DE is not one of them. Tonight could have had a catastrophic ending. The matter will be reviewed thoroughly.’’

Younger told Cleveland.com that he is leaving open the possibility of pursuing assault charges.

BUD SHAW'S SPORTS SPIN: If Myles Garrett’s season is over, he can appeal but he really can’t complain

JIMMY'S TAKE: Fight involving Myles Garrett at end of Browns game was 'absolutely disgusting'

Before You Leave, Check This Out