Breaking News
More () »

3News Investigates: Attorneys seek release of thousands of Ohio inmates

Rising COVID-19 cases in state prison alarm inmate families, AG Yost unmoved.

CLEVELAND — Attorneys for several Ohio inmates are requesting Gov. Mike DeWine give emergency reprieves to allows tens of thousands of prisoner to be released until the COVID-19 pandemic subsides.

The filing comes on the heels of spreading coronavirus cases throughout the state prison system, capped by DeWine's announcement of the first inmate death connected to COVID-19.

Last week, DeWine announced the first death of a state prison correction officer at the Marion Correctional Institution.

On Monday, the governor said 146 inmates and 119 staff members have tested positive for the coronavirus.

Prisons and jails across Ohio and the nation have been plagued by the spread of the coronavirus. At the Elkton federal prison near Warren, 24 inmates and 14 staff members have tested positive. Three inmates have died.

RELATED: Exclusive 3News Investigation: Families of inmates met with silence as COVID-19 overwhelms Elkton prison

Similar concerns have been raised at the Cuyahoga County Jail, where 21 inmates have tested positive.

RELATED: 21 inmates at Cuyahoga County Jail have now tested positive for coronavirus

Attorneys representing four Ohio inmates filed for an emergency reprieve last week, noting the high infection rate, the national death toll, and the ongoing struggles with incarcerated individuals nationwide.

"It's really difficult not be scared for his safety and health," said Azzurra Crispino, whose husband, James, is serving 17 years in prison for robbery. He is eligible for early release this summer, she said.

Credit: Submitted

Crispino is hoping he won’t have to wait that long.

"The only way to stop the spread of this virus is decrease the number of people behind prison walls," she said. "We need to take extreme and immediate steps to be [releasing] as many people as possible."

Cleveland attorney Sarah Gelsomino, of the Friedman and Gilbert law firm, partnered with attorneys from Patituce and Associates, to draft the motion for emergency reprieve.

The attorneys are asking DeWine to release thousands of eligible inmates in an effort to ease the spread and threat of COVID-19.

"The governor has the ability under the law - to without a hearing and without review - release prisoners, in mass on reprieve," Gelsominoi told 3News Investigator Rachel Polansky.

The reprieve does not mean inmates would be sent home for good. Rather, the inmates would see their sentence temporarily suspended for the duration of the COVID-19 pandemic. They would then return to prison to complete their sentence.

"We know the governor has executive power, should he choose to use it," she said.

DeWine last week started taking steps to release 167 inmates to help ease concerns. He whittled the number down to ensure violent offenders are not released.

RELATED: Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine identifies 167 inmates for potential release due to coronavirus emergency

Inmate advocates, however, say the 167 inmates targeted for release will do little to ease concerns. Those inmates represent about 0.3 percent of the approximate 49,000 inmate population.

"That is a drop in the bucket," Gelsomino said.

Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost agreed. And he's pleased.

"I'm glad it was only a drop in the bucket," Yost said.

Ohio prisons, he said, are filled with serious, violent criminals, many of whom have extensive histories of misconduct.

"Our prisons have dangerous people in them," he said. "The notion that because they might catch a bug that they have a great chance of recovering from...that we ought to just open the doors of the prisons and let everybody out, is an absurdity."

"Even in the above 60 cohort, [COVID-19] is not a death sentence...96.5% over 60 have recovered from this disease."

Chazidy Bowman, the wife of inmate Rufus Bowman, who is serving time for robbery and felonious assault at the Toledo Correctional Institution, said not all inmates are as violent as their convictions would lead many to believe.

Regardless, she said the state of Ohio is entrusted to keep inmates in a safe environment, and they cannot do that under the current, cramped and overcrowded conditions.

Credit: Submitted

"We're afraid they’re going to get sick and die," she said. "This virus inside the prison is like trapping a tornado inside a box, and it’s going to spin out of control."

RELATED: State of Ohio begins coronavirus testing for all inmates at 3 facilities

Click here for our special coronavirus section.

RELATED: Dr. Amy Acton: General public could be wearing masks for the next year

RELATED: Ohio's Mike DeWine denies rift between governors and President Trump

RELATED: Ohio coronavirus update: 6,975 cases, 274 deaths; Gov. DeWine restricts liquor sales in several counties to Ohio residents only

RELATED: Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine issues order requiring nursing homes to notify residents, families of positive coronavirus tests

RELATED: Gov. Mike DeWine limits liquor store purchases to only Ohioans in several counties

RELATED: University Hospitals receives 30,000 masks from community; Still asking for help to sew 100,000 for caregivers

Before You Leave, Check This Out